Cream stucco terrace with closed arched bronze-framed doors, terracotta roof tiles, limestone paving, and one flowering frangipani in a clay planter.

Movie Theaters Near Pelican Marsh Naples: What Is Changing

For Pelican Marsh residents, the two closest movie theaters sit across U.S. 41 from each other, west along Vanderbilt Beach Road. One has been dark since Sept. 9. The other is about to get smaller. By early 2027, if the plan holds, one company will run both.

That company is Paragon Theaters. Paragon's co-owner wants 17 screens across Mercato and The Pavilion. Today the two buildings hold 21. This fall and winter, the fewer screens, the hand-off between buildings, the film festival and the roadwork all come back to that choice.

The Mercato Screens Went Dark on Sept. 9

The Mercato theater has had three operators in under three years. Silverspot Cinema closed there in July 2023. Alamo Drafthouse Cinema opened in the space on April 29, 2024, as the chain's first Florida location, WINK News reported. Its final day was Sept. 9, 2026.

The closure left 11 empty screens at Mercato and took Alamo out of Florida altogether, since this was its only location in the state. Paragon Pavilion at 833 Vanderbilt Beach Road is now the only cinema on this stretch of the road, and it will stay that way until Mercato reopens.

Paragon Is Counting Screens Down to 17

When Paragon moves into Mercato, it plans to get smaller overall. Its co-CEO and co-owner, Michael Whalen, explained the reasoning to Gulfshore Business columnist Tim Aten:

"We are trying to rationalize the screens in the marketplace and how many we have. So, ideally, I would like to have 11 screens at Mercato and six at Pavilion, so for a total of 17 screens."

The four Pavilion screens that would close are not inside the main theater. They fill a separate 9,850-square-foot freestanding building at the back of the shopping center's northwest corner, joined to the main Paragon by a hallway near the bar. The space has changed hands before. In Whalen's telling to Gulfshore Business, it started as a 10-screen theater, shrank to six screens when Tuesday Morning moved in, then went back to 10 after Paragon took over the Tuesday Morning space.

What happens to that box afterward is still open. Regency Centers, which owns The Pavilion, told Gulfshore Business it has the option to take the old Tuesday Morning space back and lease it to another tenant. Whalen mentioned interest from an indoor soccer operator and from the cycle shop already in the center. He is also considering keeping the space himself for about six golf simulators. Either way, the target stays at six movie screens there.

The Mercato lease was still described as likely, not signed, in Gulfshore Business's Oct. 9, 2026 update. Everything below about Mercato is the stated plan, not a finished deal.

This fall Planned once Paragon Mercato opens
Paragon Pavilion, 833 Vanderbilt Beach Road All 10 screens running through the holidays Six screens
Mercato, former Alamo Drafthouse Closed until Paragon opens 11 screens as Paragon Mercato
Former Tuesday Morning box at The Pavilion Four Paragon screens New tenant or a non-cinema use, possibly golf simulators
Total screens on the corridor 10 17

Why the Opening Date Depends on a Chair

Paragon's target for opening Mercato is Dec. 18, the day the new Avengers and Dune sequels come out. Whalen has said he will not open without the company's Lux Box seating in every auditorium. He told Gulfshore Business the seats look delayed. In that case, he said, "it's probably a beginning of January event now." He added that he is "still trying to shoot for the 18th."

Gulfshore Business's earlier report on the Alamo closure called the project "Paragon Mercato." It described Axis15 Extreme auditoriums plus Lux Box dine-in recliners, with food ordered and brought to your seat. The final amenity list, including whether Mercato gets a bar, has not been announced.

Whalen said the Pavilion will keep "operating those four screens probably minimally until the end of the year," so all 10 Pavilion screens should be showing films through the holidays. If the opening slips to January, the Pavilion carries the whole holiday movie season alone.

The Film Festival Arrives During the Gap

The 18th annual Naples International Film Festival runs Thursday, Oct. 22, through Sunday, Oct. 25, 2026, according to the official Artis Naples schedule. Screenings are listed at Artis Naples and on Paragon screens 2 through 5. Some press coverage lists Oct. 23 to 25. The festival's own calendar starts on Thursday the 22nd.

Opening night is a shorts program in Hayes Hall. The closing-night event is Superman, with the Naples Philharmonic playing John Williams' score live.

This is the same Paragon screen count that changes next year, and Whalen has already linked the two. He told Gulfshore Business the festival was at The Pavilion two years ago too. He said the 2027 edition could land at either building. "Mercato's a little bit higher-end for the film festival people," he said. He added that a six-screen Pavilion "could actually just be the film festival itself without any other outside movies," because the festival could rent the whole place. If the plan goes ahead, the smaller Pavilion could host the whole festival in a building it fully fills.

The Corridor Calendar, October Through Spring

Here is how the season lines up for anyone driving west from Pelican Marsh on Vanderbilt Beach Road:

  1. September. Sour & Dough Artisan Bakery opens at 893 Vanderbilt Beach Road, Unit 58, inside The Pavilion. It sells French-style breads, pastries, sandwiches and specialty coffee, and its soft-opening hours were 8:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. daily, according to Gulfshore Business. Those hours suit a matinee better than an evening show.
  2. Sept. 9, 2026. Alamo Drafthouse closes at Mercato.
  3. Oct. 22–25, 2026. The Naples International Film Festival screens at Artis Naples and Paragon.
  4. Through the holidays. All 10 Pavilion screens stay open.
  5. Dec. 18, or early January. Paragon Mercato's target opening, per Gulfshore Business's Oct. 9, 2026 update, depending on when the Lux Box seats arrive.
  6. Spring 2027. Vanderbilt Beach Road drops to one lane each way for about two months between Strada Place and Goodlette-Frank Road.

The Road to Mercato Narrows in Spring

The last item on that list affects the trip to the new theater. Collier County is widening about 1.8 miles of Vanderbilt Beach Road, from just east of U.S. 41 to near Fontana Del Sol Way. The county issued its notice to proceed in early June 2026 and estimates about two years of construction, with daytime lane closures along the way, according to the county's transportation engineering projects page.

The county expects its most disruptive phase in spring 2027, when traffic narrows to one lane each way for about two months between Strada Place and Goodlette-Frank Road. If Paragon opens on its December or January schedule, the stretch of Vanderbilt Beach Road leading to Mercato will be at its narrowest during the new theater's first spring season. Evening showtimes will probably avoid the daytime lane closures. A weekday matinee at Mercato next spring is more likely to run into them.

When a theater changes hands, the businesses around it often feel it too. Chiodo Group follows changes like the Mercato and Pavilion reshuffle because they affect daily life in Pelican Marsh. If you are wondering how the Vanderbilt Beach Road corridor fits into what your home is worth this season, start with an instant home valuation and we can talk through the details.

Work With Us

Our team members, coming from various cultural and linguistic backgrounds, provide an expansive network of assistance, ensuring our clients receive the best possible guidance and support.

Follow Us on Instagram